Short answer
Private cloud runs your workloads on infrastructure dedicated to you. Public cloud runs them on shared hyperscale platforms such as Azure or AWS.
In detail: Private cloud vs public cloud: which should you choose
In a private cloud, compute, storage and networking are reserved for one organisation, either in your own data centre or hosted and run by a provider. You still get virtual servers, self-service and automation, but with dedicated resources and a known location. In a public cloud, the provider runs a very large shared platform and you rent capacity and managed services by the hour or the gigabyte, scaling up or down on demand. Hybrid cloud combines the two, connected privately, and is the most common setup today.
How private and public cloud compare:
- Control: private cloud gives dedicated resource pools and predictable performance; public cloud abstracts the hardware and shares it across many customers.
- Cost model: private cloud is usually a steady monthly cost per vCPU, GB of RAM and GB of storage; public cloud bills on consumption, which suits variable demand but needs active cost management.
- Services: public cloud offers far more platform services, such as managed databases, AI services and virtual desktops; private cloud focuses on infrastructure for your existing servers.
- Scaling: public cloud scales almost instantly for bursts; private cloud scales within planned capacity.
- Migration: existing VMware or Hyper-V servers usually lift and shift into private cloud with little change, while public cloud often rewards re-architecting.
- Data location: both can keep data in South Africa, but with private cloud you know exactly which facility holds it.
Private cloud suits steady, regulated or latency-sensitive systems, predictable budgets and teams that want to keep their hypervisor skills. Public cloud suits development and test, burst workloads, global reach and modern platform-as-a-service applications. Private cloud is a poor fit for workloads that swing sharply in size, and public cloud can become expensive for large, always-on servers that nobody right-sizes.
For South African organisations, POPIA makes data location and governance a design question. Keeping data in South Africa supports POPIA-aligned designs, but compliance is shared: your configuration, data classification and governance still decide the outcome. Billing currency matters too, since many public cloud contracts are priced in US dollars.
Questions to ask a cloud provider:
- Where exactly will our workloads and backups be hosted, and where will disaster recovery run?
- Which certifications cover the platform, and for which sites?
- How are backups protected against ransomware?
- How does the private platform connect to Azure, AWS or Google Cloud?
- What is the exit process, and who owns the data?
FirstNet delivers both sides. FirstNet Private Cloud is a South African-hosted Infrastructure as a Service platform in FirstNet data centres in Durban, Johannesburg and Cape Town, on VMware vSphere or Microsoft Hyper-V, with Dell PowerEdge compute and Infinidat tiered storage. A virtual firewall and Veeam backups to immutable storage form the recommended baseline, and you can add Server Management for operating system monitoring and patching, or Geographic DR to a second FirstNet data centre. FirstNet operates ISO 27001 and ISO 9001 certified management systems that cover the platform. Private Cloud is not a public-cloud-style multi-region active/active service: site failover runs through Geographic DR.
For public cloud, FirstNet supplies Azure through its Microsoft CSP agreement, with landing zone design and a single rand invoice. Private peering links FirstNet Private Cloud to AWS, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud Platform, so hybrid traffic does not rely on the public internet. You own your data, and an exit with secure deprovisioning and data handover is available under your contract.
A FirstNet discovery workshop maps each workload to private, public or hybrid cloud before any migration timeline is set.
Source: FirstNet Private Cloud Hosting & Management service page →